To begin I needed to pick four materials to test. My objective was to see if they were good insulators of heat. I selected aluminum foil, plastic, oven mitt, and small piece of foam.
My educated guess (hypothesis) was that the plastic, foam, and mitt would be the best insulators and the aluminum would lose heat much faster than the others would. Since aluminum foil is a metal it is consider to be a conductor not an insulator.
My next step was to set up the experiment. I used several ceramic coffee cups from my kitchen, the thermometer found in Walden’s science kit, a piece of aluminum foil, plastic wrap, a oven mitt, and a piece of foam cut from a foam cup. After setting up the lab, the next step was to perform the experiment. I read and followed experimental procedure as written. The four coffee cups were placed in a row on an even surface and each received three-fourths cups of hot water. After which I measured the temperature The temperatures varied a little for several of the cups. The cup I covered with plastic wrap and the mitt measure 36 degrees Celsius. The cup I covered with foil and foam measured 38 degrees. Once the temperatures were recorded the cups were securely cover with the preselected material (aluminum foil, foam, oven mitt, and plastic). I decided to observe the material in 15 min interval for a period of thirty minutes.
After the fifteen period ended, I removed each of the covers from the mugs. At the end of the fifteen minute interval the cup covered with the mitt and plastic wrap measured 32 degrees Celsius. The cups with the mitt and with the foil measured 30 degrees Celsius, and the cup with the foam measured 36 degrees Celsius. I recovered each cup for a additional 15 minutes. At the end of 15 minute interval a total of 30 minutes, the cups covered with plastic and mitt measured 28 degrees Celsius. The cup covered with foil measured 26 degrees Celsius. And the cup with the foam measured 34 degrees Celsius.
In conclusion the inquiry experience performed as expected. The cups with foam proved to be the best insulator. The cups with plastic and the mitt were about the same. The cup with the foil was the poorest insulator.
In addition, this lab would be a good hands-on activity for my students . There are several thing that I would change one is the amount of time provided between intervals. I would need to include addition question and discussion while the student wait to measure temperatures. Also, I notice that it was a little more difficult to measure temperature with only one thermometer. The lag time between measurements could affect the accuracy of the results. Also the lab could be expanded to allow student to investigate using a control cup. This way the students will be able to observe how heat transfer reacts with out insulators.
Tillery, B. W., Enger, E. D., & Ross, F. C. (2008). Integrated science (4th ed.).
New York: MGraw-Hill.
I am surprised by the results from your aluminum foil covered mug, especially that it lost more heat than the plastic wrap. I ended up with completely opposite results. Even though I knew the foil was the best conductor, I thought it would also hold the heat in best because of the tight fit and the closeness of the molecules within it. Do you think part of the reason it lost more heat was because it started at a lower tempertaure?
ReplyDeleteI agree that if I did this with my students that I would have them measure the temperature at different intervals. I wonder if some of the materials lose more heat at the beginning that others.I also think it would be a good idea to have a control cup as part of the experiment.
I like the idea of monitoring your temperature in 15 minute interval for the 30 minute allotted time frame. What effect, if any, do you think removing the materials, in order to monitor of the temperatures, had on the final temperature measurement? Since, in a sense the trapped vapors where released.
ReplyDeleteRosera,
ReplyDeleteI am not sure what happen with the aluminum foil. I was not expecting the aluminum to lose the most heat. I figured since metal are good conductor of heat maybe some of the heat energy was transferred to the foil.
Amitchell,
ReplyDeleteI am sure that some of the heat energy was released into the air each time the coverings were removed. I tired to measure the temperature with just part of the cover removed.